Todd Gaston | Senior Pastor

In 2002, Pastor Todd accepted the position as Mount Ararat’s student pastor, and the Gastons moved to Stafford to join the Mount Ararat family. After Senior Pastor Dee Whitten accepted a position with the Baptist General Association of Virginia, a search committee was formed to find someone to fill the open position of senior pastor. Seventeen months later, the committee called Pastor Todd. Previously serving as Minister to Students at Plymouth Park Baptist Church, Pastor Todd received his bachelor of science from Stephen F. Austin State University and his master’s in religious education from Southwestern Theological Seminary in Fort Worth, Texas. Todd and his wife, Pam, have three daughters, Hannah, Sydney, and Lexie.

Brian Bennett | Executive Pastor

Brian received his undergraduate degree from the University of Alaska-Fairbanks with BA in Theatre and Business and his graduate degrees from Biola University and Trinity College of the Bible and Seminary. In 2006, after a career in the hotel industry, he entered the ministry. Brian and Therisa are blessed with three children Cheyenne, Lorarlai and Rogan. Never imagining they would find themselves in full-time vocational Christian work, they couldn’t be happier that God is using them to make disciples of Jesus.


Andy LaValley | Pastor for Worship and Arts 

After graduating from Tennessee Technological University with a bachelor of science in musical therapy, Andy attended Trinity College of the Bible Theological Seminary and went on to serve six years at Green Hills Church in Mount Juliet, Tennessee. Before coming to Mount Ararat, he held the position of Worship Pastor at Colonial Heights Baptist Church in Ridgeland, Mississippi. Pastor Andy is married to Kristen, has two sons, Jordan and Caden, and a daughter, Mia.


Susan Wanderer | Minister to Kids 

A native Virginian, Susan loved growing up in her hometown of Charlottesville. (Wahoowa!) She began her ministry at Mount Ararat in 2006 and has an amazing passion for children, their families, and seeing them coming into a growing relationship with Jesus. After graduating from Carson Newman College in East Tennessee, where she received her bachelor of arts, she attended seminary at Southeastern Seminary in Wake Forest, North Carolina. She has served at churches in Georgia, Virginia, and Florida. Susan and her husband, Ed, have three children, Joshua, Ruth and Dibora.

Jerry Williams | Garrisonville Campus Pastor 

Recently serving as Associate Pastor for spiritual formation for all ages at Green Hill Church in Mt. Juliet, Tennessee, Jerry comes with three decades of experience leading staff and volunteer teams and ministering to the church family. Born and raised in Nashville, Jerry’s greatest passion is to encourage the local church to reach beyond church walls to the community and to the world. A chaplain in the Tennessee guard, he received his bachelor of science from Middle Tennessee State University and his master's of ministry at Trinity College and Seminary in Newburgh, Indiana. Jerry is married to Lisa and has two kids: Neil (age 21, married, and studying at Southwestern Seminary to become a missionary) and daughter, Kelsey (age 17 and a senior in high school).

Andrew Segre | Courthouse Campus Pastor 

Andrew is a Florida native. After being far from God for most of his life, a friend shared the good news about Christ with Andrew, and Jesus radically began changing his life. Andrew graduated from Florida Atlantic University in 2003 with a bachelor's degree in psychology and then from Liberty University in 2006 with a master's degree in religion. He married his wife Anna in 2007 and has 3 kids – Makaiah, Noah and Lucas. Andrew’s mission in life is to see all people live life to the fullest through Christ.


All Staff

Church Office   (540) 659-2554    

Hours: Mon-Thu 8-4;  Fri 8-3




Senior Pastor Todd Gaston  
Receptionist & Senior Pastor Assistant Deb Anderson 1032
Communications Director    
Communications Videographer/Graphic Designer Neil Smith 1067
Communications  Jennifer Denmon 1007
Garrisonville Campus Pastor Jerry Williams 1028
Mnistry Care Director John Cook 1476
Connections Director Christine Franklin 1045
Adult Ministry Assistant/Calendar Coordinator Karen Holt 1091
Adult Ministry Communications Assistant Michele Allen 1429
Student Director    
Student Ministry Worship Director    1265
Student Ministry Assistant Ann Butterfield 1468
Minister to Kids Susan Wanderer 1463
Kid Event, Access and Awana Director Jaime Breth 1074
Weekday Preschool Director Michele Ashinhurst 1075
Weekday Preschool Assistant Stacey Tuckwiller 1492
Elementary Director Linda Elliott 1428
Elementary Small Groups Director Debbie Cook 1463
Elementary Small Groups Director Sharon Danielson 1463
Elementary Assistant  Kristy Nichols 1463
Sunday Preschool Director Imani Stokes 1529
Sunday Preschool Asst Director Shannon Dougherty 1528
Sunday Preschool Admin Assistant Sarah Thomas 1025
Childcare Corrdinator Kristy Freeman 1025
Pastor for Worship & Arts Andy LaValley 1512
Worship Director Becca Griffitts 1512
Audio/Tech Director Andy Brooks 1512
Production/Tech Director Katie Robbins 1512

Executive Pastor Brian Bennett 2434
Financial Assistant  Pattie Batt 1029
Financial Assistant Susan Rogers 1051
Office Manager Pat Crooks 1340
Facilities Manager Paul LaMar 1069
Database Coordinator Brady Swisher 1053
Courthouse Campus Pastor Andrew Segre 1513
Courthouse Worship Director
Josh Einwechter  1024
Courthouse Family Life Director Deb Einwechter  1581